Milburn Review: Employers have a vital role in preventing a ‘lost generation’ of young people

Senior supervisor brainstorming with young staff in a modern office as part of a workplace training programme.

The landmark Milburn review calls for a fundamental rethink of how young people are supported into work, with employers being urged to create more first chances – and ensure those opportunities lead to sustainable careers.

Nearly one million young people in the UK are not in education, employment or training (NEET). Around six in ten have never had a job. And the problem, argues Alan Milburn’s long-awaited Review of Young People and Work, is not a lack of aspiration among young people, but a system that is failing to connect them with the opportunities and support they need.

Published today (17 November), From a Welfare State to a Working State: A new settlement for the next generation proposes a far-reaching overhaul of employment, education, health and welfare support. Its ambition is to reduce the proportion of 16–24-year-olds who are NEET to around 5% by 2036, creating approximately 500,000 additional opportunities in education and employment.

The review has been welcomed by the Government as a potential watershed moment, with ministers endorsing its central principles and committing to a fundamental rethink. But while much of the attention will inevitably focus on welfare reform, the implications for employers are considerable.

The message is clear: creating more routes into work must be part of the solution, but getting young people through the door is only the beginning.

What is the review proposing?

At the heart of Milburn’s recommendations is a proposed Young People’s Opportunity and Support Guarantee, giving young people who are not earning or learning a credible route into education, training, an apprenticeship, high-quality work experience or a job – alongside the health, employment and practical support needed to take up that opportunity and sustain it.

Other key proposals include:

  • A new local Youth Opportunity Service: bringing employment, careers, education, skills, health and wider support together, with a named adviser and a personalised plan rather than expecting young people to navigate fragmented services themselves.
  • More opportunities to gain experience and skills: expanding apprenticeships, pre-apprenticeship routes, work placements and supported internships, while strengthening the links between education and employment.
  • A national First Chance employer movement: bringing businesses together to create more first jobs, apprenticeships and meaningful work experience, and encouraging employers to recognise potential rather than rely on traditional qualifications or previous experience.
  • Financial incentives for employers: including proposed recruitment payments for taking on young people who are NEET, with additional support for those facing greater barriers and smaller employers. The review also proposes increasing apprenticeship incentives and, when fiscal conditions allow, reducing employer National Insurance costs for 21–24-year-olds in sectors including retail and hospitality.
  • Earlier and better health support: recognising the impact of mental ill-health, disability and neurodevelopmental conditions on young people’s ability to enter and remain in work, with proposals for faster access to support and more joined-up services.

The review also recommends significant changes to welfare provision for under-25s, with a greater emphasis on participation and routes into work, while retaining a stronger safety net for those with the most severe and enduring conditions. These proposals will require careful scrutiny, particularly in relation to disabled young people and those with fluctuating health conditions.

The Government has committed to the Opportunity and Support Guarantee and a new locally led service, alongside a Youth Opportunities Unit at the heart of government. It will set out further details in a White Paper in early 2027.

Employers are already responding

The publication has prompted a strong response from employers, many of whom are signalling their support for the review and the First Chance ambition.

For Heather Smith, CEO of AXA Health, the report is a reminder that employers have a responsibility not only to open the door to employment, but to help young people build sustainable and rewarding careers.

Drawing on AXA Health’s Starting Out, Staying In research, she highlights in a post on LinkedIn how mental health challenges can affect confidence, job retention and future opportunities from the very start of working life. Good management, clear communication, respect and access to appropriate support can make the difference between simply getting a job and genuinely thriving at work.

Also posting on LinkedIn, Howden has also pledged its support for First Chance, pointing to the need to rethink recruitment and recognise potential regardless of background or traditional pathways. Its actions include changing recruitment processes, offering feedback to unsuccessful apprenticeship applicants and committing £1.1 million of unused Growth and Skills Levy funding to support young people in underserved communities.

The message from Howden is that this must be more than a series of individual commitments. First Chance needs to become a wider movement of employers setting clear goals, sharing progress and taking responsibility for creating lasting opportunities.

BT Group is focusing on quality work experience, closer partnerships with schools and colleges, and clearer routes into apprenticeships and employment, recognising that the UK’s digital future depends as much on people as technology.

Meanwhile, Manchester Airports Group (MAG) points to the impact of its Aerozones, Airport Academies, Manchester Airport Skills Hub and Stansted Airport College. Its education and employment programmes have supported more than 103,000 people over five years, including more than 350 young people classed as NEET in the past year.

These examples demonstrate that employers can make a tangible difference by connecting young people with workplaces, building skills and confidence, and creating routes into employment that might otherwise remain out of reach.

Getting into work is only half the challenge

There is, however, an important distinction between creating opportunities and ensuring young people can sustain them.

Sarah McIntosh, Chief Executive of MHFA England and the Association of Mental Health First Aiders, draws attention to one of the review’s most important observations: “Starts matter. Retention and progression matter more.”

A first job is a significant milestone, but whether a young person stays will depend heavily on what happens after day one. Having a manager who listens, feeling respected and knowing where to turn when things become difficult all matter.

In her post on LinkedIn, McIntosh explains that she sees mental health first aid as one part of the support available in the workplace, providing access to a trained colleague who can notice when someone is struggling and help them take the first step towards further support. It is not a solution in itself, but it can contribute to a more supportive working environment.

This is an important point for employers. Recruiting young people into entry-level roles, apprenticeships and placements will not deliver lasting change if those workplaces are not equipped to support them, particularly when they are navigating mental health challenges or other barriers to employment.

The questions that still need answering

While there is considerable support for the review’s ambition, its recommendations raise important questions about implementation.

Ben Harrison, Director of the Work Foundation, argues in his LinkedIn post that additional employment and health support must be funded and introduced ahead of welfare reforms. He also warns against setting employment and welfare in opposition to one another, pointing out that 45.3% of NEET young people are disabled.

The availability and quality of jobs matter too. Harrison highlights the decline in entry-level vacancies, with particularly acute shortages in some parts of the country. He argues that new opportunities must not come at the expense of secure employment, noting that young people are already disproportionately affected by insecure work and precarious zero-hours contracts.

For BSI’s Global Head Human and Social Sustainability, Kate Field, another critical issue is the impact of artificial intelligence on entry-level employment.

She welcomes the review’s proposal for an AI Youth Observatory to monitor how AI adoption is affecting opportunities for young people. Drawing on BSI’s Human by Design research, she points to evidence that automation is already reducing entry-level opportunities in some organisations. The challenge, she argues, is to understand where the first rung of the career ladder is disappearing fastest – and what new opportunities are emerging in its place.

PwC UK chair Marco Amitrano similarly argues that the country cannot afford to leave nearly one million young people outside education, employment or training while businesses are looking for the skills they need to grow. He sees the review as a call for government, employers, educators and communities to work together, building on initiatives such as First Chance and sector-led employment plans.

The Institute for Employment Studies also welcomes the emphasis on bringing opportunities and support together around each young person. Its Chief Executive, Naomi Clayton, cautions that better support alone cannot create the jobs young people need. Employers must be supported – and challenged – to recruit without insisting on prior experience, offer flexibility where necessary and provide effective training.

For young people with disabilities and additional needs, the importance of meaningful, properly supported routes into work is particularly clear. DFN Project SEARCH has welcomed the review’s recognition of supported internships as part of the solution, while emphasising that scaling them up will require sustained investment and better coordination between government, local authorities, education providers and employers.

From ambition to lasting change

The Milburn Review sets out a compelling case for moving from a system that responds to young people becoming detached from work and education to one that intervenes earlier, creates genuine opportunities and provides the support needed to sustain participation.

For employers, this is not simply about filling vacancies or meeting recruitment targets. It is about rethinking how potential is recognised, how young people experience their first years at work, and whether organisations are creating environments in which people can develop and progress.

The response from businesses suggests there is appetite to play a bigger part. But the real test will be whether commitments translate into more first jobs, apprenticeships and meaningful work experience – and whether those opportunities lead to secure, rewarding and sustainable careers.

As Milburn’s review makes clear, the cost of failing to act is too high, for young people, employers and the wider economy. The challenge now is to turn its ambition into a coordinated programme of action that delivers lasting change.

You might also like:

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/from-a-welfare-state-to-a-working-state-a-new-settlement-for-the-next-generation

LATEST POLL

Sponsored by:
FEATURED